Volume 3: What Can Go Wrong, and Your Plan · Chapter 8
Your Bank Bonus Plan
One page to decide if a bank bonus is worth it: what it earns, whether savings pays more, what you keep after tax, your hours and each date.
- Read time: 7 min
- Complexity: Intermediate
- Topic: Planning
SwitchWize Research DeskReviewed by Jay Rege, Head of Financial Research, on Oct 5, 2026Updated Oct 5, 2026
The short answer
Each chapter answers one question about a bank bonus. This one puts the answers on one page for one offer. It does not rank offers, and credit card bonuses are not covered. Do checks 1 to 4 first. If the answer is not clearly good, stop. If you already opened an account, start with the dates in check 6.
Check 1: What does the bonus earn you?
Subtract fees from the bonus, divide by the average money you keep in the account, then scale to a year. The result is a yearly rate, not a savings rate. Bank A is made up: a $400 bonus, $15 of fees, and $4,000 kept for 90 days. You keep $385, which is 9.63% over the 90 days and 39.03% a year. That looks high because your money stays only a quarter of a year. What a Bank Account Bonus Really Pays shows a bigger balance, where the rate drops a lot.
Check 2: Does it pay more than savings?
The same $4,000 in savings at a made-up 4.00% earns $39.45 in 90 days. The bonus account pays no interest, so you give that up. The bonus still pays $345.55 more. Savings would need to pay 39.03% to match it. The 4.00% is a placeholder, so use today's rate and redo the math the day you decide.
Chapter 2 deep diveBank Bonus or Savings Rate: Which Pays More?This chapter gives the matching savings rate and a table by balance and time, so you can see how fast the gap closes.Check 3: What do you keep after tax?
A cash bonus is generally taxable income. Use your own rates. This example uses a made-up 22% federal and 5% state rate, 27% together. After that tax, your $15 of fees, and the savings interest you give up (also taxed), you keep $248.20. You owe the tax whether or not a form arrives. This is information, not tax advice.
Chapter 3 deep diveAre Bank Bonuses Taxable? What to Expect at Tax TimeThis chapter covers the tax forms, the federal brackets and the state rates, with sources, so you can fill in your own two rates.Check 4: Is it worth your hours?
Count the hours for the whole job: reading terms, applying, adding money, moving your direct deposit, tracking and closing. Say it takes 4 hours. Then $248.20 is $62.05 an hour. If you value an hour at $25, the bonus pays well. One missed step can cost the whole bonus while the hours are still spent, so weigh that risk first.
Chapter 4 deep diveIs a Bank Bonus Worth Your Time?This chapter works through different amounts of effort and the cost of one more account to manage.Check 5: Can you get the bonus?
Do this early, because a bonus you cannot get is worth nothing. Find four things in the offer's own words. First, the new-customer rule. Second, how far back the bank checks. Third, any limit per person or household. Fourth, any state or branch rule. Write each answer on your page with the date you read the terms. If you are not sure an old account counts, ask the bank in writing before you open.
Chapter 5 deep diveWho Can Get a Bank Bonus? Reading the Fine PrintThis chapter gives a checklist for reading the new-customer rule, how far back the bank looks, and the bank's screening.Check 6: What must you do, and by when?
Write each rule on its own line: what, how much, by which day. Then write four dates: when the clock starts, when you must finish, when the bank should pay, and when you may close. Your money must stay until the bank pays you. With more than one offer, put every date on one list. Start a new offer only after you close out the last one.
The deposit-bonus tracker at /dashboard/tracking holds your deadline and amounts and emails you 14 days and 3 days before it. It requires an account. It does not connect to your bank, so you confirm the bonus arrived.
Chapter 6 deep diveDirect Deposit Rules and How Long Your Money Must StayThis chapter shows how to read a deposit rule and the waiting time, and what to write down at each step. Chapter 7 deep diveHow You Can Lose a Bank Bonus: Fees, Early Closing and Other TrapsThis chapter covers how you can lose a bonus after you meet the target, and the checklist before you close.Estimate the after-tax cash value of a bank direct-deposit bonus after account fees during the required holding period.
A cash bonus is generally taxable income; which form reports it is not fixed by IRS text, so check the form you receive. Enter your own combined marginal assumption.
Effective Monthly After-Tax Bonus Value
$76
Use this result as one input in your broader Money Map, not as a one-off number.
What to do
Compare high-yield savings rates
Estimates use your entered assumptions. Confirm the relevant rules before acting.
The one-page plan
Copy this table and fill it in for one offer. Dates count from the day you open the account.
- What to write
- The day
- Example (made up)
- Day 0
- What to write
- Clause and date
- Example (made up)
- Yes
- What to write
- Dollars
- Example (made up)
- $400, $15
- What to write
- Dollars, days
- Example (made up)
- $4,000, 90 days
- What to write
- Check 1
- Example (made up)
- 39.03%
- What to write
- Check 3
- Example (made up)
- $248.20
- What to write
- Check 4
- Example (made up)
- 4 hours, $25
- What to write
- A day
- Example (made up)
- Day 90
- What to write
- After the bonus arrives
- Example (made up)
- Day 95
- What to write
- Go, skip or wait
- Example (made up)
- Go
In plain words: you read the terms on day 0. The bank should pay by day 90. On day 95 you see the bonus, then close the account. Use your own offer's deadlines.
Fill in the first rows before you open the account. Fill in the dates the same day, and put them on your calendar. If any row is blank or a number looks thin, wait or skip. A blank row means you do not yet know what the offer asks of you. Skipping costs nothing, while a missed rule can cost the whole bonus.
What do you do at the end?
- Confirm the bonus arrived and matches the offer.
- Check whether the terms say the account must stay open longer.
- Save the date and amount for your tax return.
- Move your direct deposit and payments.
- Close the account last, and mark the tracker entry done.
Chapter 7 deep diveWhat Can Go Wrong When You Switch BanksThe switching chapter covers deposit holds, autopay gaps and account checks that can disturb your plan when you move your money.Limits of this guide.
- The plan does not pick a bank or rank an offer.
- It uses only the numbers you enter. You confirm the amounts that arrived.
- The 4.00% savings rate is a placeholder, and the tax step is a simple estimate.
- Skipping an offer is a good choice.
Want to run your own numbers? Try the bank bonus vs savings calculator.
Frequently asked questions
How do I keep track of a bank bonus?
Write one plan per offer with the requirement, the amounts, each deadline, the day the bonus should arrive and the day you will close the account. The deposit-bonus tracker in your SwitchWize dashboard holds the deadline and amounts and sends reminders as the deadline gets close; it requires an account. It does not read your bank, so you confirm the amounts yourself.
Should I take every bank bonus I qualify for?
No. Each offer is a separate decision. Run the checks in this plan: what you earn on the money you tie up, what the same money would earn in savings, what you keep after tax, and your hours. If any check leaves too little, or a rule is hard to keep track of, the better choice can be to skip the bonus.
In what order should I check an offer?
Start with the check that can end it fastest. Read who can get the bonus first, because a bonus you cannot receive is worth nothing. Then check what it earns, whether savings pays more, what you keep after tax, and your hours. Write the dates only after the offer meets your own checks. This order spends the least time on offers that fail early.
When can I close the account?
Only after the bonus has arrived and you have checked whether the offer says the account must stay open longer. The terms differ by offer. Close the account last, after you move your direct deposit and payments, and keep a record of the date and amount of the bonus for your tax return.
Sources
Educational content, not individualized financial, tax or legal advice. Examples use hypothetical figures unless a source is cited. Report an error at our corrections page.