Volume 1: What a Bonus Is Really Worth · Chapter 2

Bank Bonus or Savings Rate: Which Pays More?

Find the savings rate at which a bank bonus and a savings account pay the same on your money, and the smallest bonus worth chasing.

  • Read time: 6 min
  • Complexity: Intermediate
  • Topic: Bonus vs savings

SwitchWize Research DeskReviewed by Jay Rege, Head of Financial Research, on Oct 5, 2026Updated Nov 1, 2026

The short answer

To see whether a bank bonus beats savings, compare it with the interest the same money would earn in savings over the same days. Divide the bonus by your balance and scale to a year. That is the break-even rate. If your savings rate is lower, the bonus pays more.
Chapter 1 deep diveShould You Switch Savings Accounts? When the Move Pays for ItselfThat Switching chapter prices a move between savings accounts. This one prices a bonus against leaving the money where a savings rate can reach it.

Our chapter on what a bonus really pays turned a bonus into a yearly rate. This chapter asks what that money could have earned in savings instead.

How do you tell which pays more?

The break-even rate is the savings rate where the bonus and savings pay the same. If the savings rate you can get is lower, the bonus pays more. If it is higher, savings pays more.

Money in savings earns balance x rate x days / 365. Three numbers follow:

  • Interest you give up: the savings interest you miss by keeping the money in the bonus account. If that account pays nothing, it is all of it.
  • How much the bonus wins by: the bonus minus the interest you give up. A negative number means savings pays more.
  • Break-even rate: bonus / balance x 365 / days x 100.

The math adds no interest on interest. It leaves out tax and your time. A bonus is never part of an APY, so this chapter compares dollars earned over the same days.

What does it look like with made-up numbers?

Bank A pays a $300 bonus. Its account pays no interest. Your savings account pays a made-up 4.00%, only to show the steps.

Say you keep $10,000 for 90 days. Savings would earn $10,000 x 4.00% x 90 / 365 = $98.63. The bonus beats that by $201.37. The break-even rate is $300 / $10,000 x 365 / 90 = 12.17%. Savings would have to pay 12.17% to match the bonus.

If Bank A's account paid a made-up 0.50%, the bonus would win by $213.70 and the break-even rate would be 12.67%. Interest the bonus account pays is interest you do not give up.

The savings rate where the bonus stops winning, in percent

If your savings rate is below the number, the bonus pays more.

$2,000
60 days
91.25
90 days
60.83
180 days
30.42
$5,000
60 days
36.50
90 days
24.33
180 days
12.17
$10,000
60 days
18.25
90 days
12.17
180 days
6.08
$25,000
60 days
7.30
90 days
4.87
180 days
2.43

Balance and days matter most. A bigger balance or a longer wait lowers the break-even rate. A smaller balance or a shorter wait raises it. With $25,000 for 180 days, the bonus matches savings at 2.43%. At 4.00%, savings pays more by $193.15.

Which pays more, in four steps
  1. Write the numbers

    The bonus, the balance you will really keep, and the most days the account must stay open.

  2. Work out the break-even rate

    Bonus / balance x 365 / days x 100.

  3. Compare with your savings rate

    Use the rate you can get today, not a short-term teaser.

  4. Read the result

    Break-even above your savings rate: the bonus pays more. Below it: savings pays more.

Four steps: write the bonus, balance and days; compute the break-even rate; compare it with the savings rate you can get; read the result.

For a benchmark, the savings rate we track, refreshed with each site build, is 4.40% APY. It is not an offer, and the rate you can get depends on the account.

Which money counts?

Only money that would otherwise have earned a savings rate.

  • Money you move out of savings to qualify. Every day in the bonus account costs you savings interest. This is the case in the table.
  • Money that sat in low-rate checking anyway. You give up very little, so the bonus looks even better.
  • Pay that arrives and is spent. If an offer wants $7,500 of direct deposits, paychecks that leave within days can meet that. Your average balance is far lower, so the break-even rate is far higher.

What does one real offer pay, as of October 5, 2026?

Real-offer check, as of October 5, 2026

This is a dated snapshot of one offer, taken from the bank's own page. It is not a recommendation or a ranking. Offers change, so check the bank's page before you act.

Next re-check due November 4, 2026.

The American Express Rewards Checking offer page states a $300 cash bonus for $7,500 or more of qualifying direct deposits that post within 90 days of opening. The bonus may take up to 8 to 12 weeks to pay after you meet the requirements. The account must stay open and in good standing until the bonus is delivered. The last day to open an eligible account is February 1, 2027. The page states no monthly fees; the account schedule governs.

The page also limits who can get the bonus. It excludes anyone who has or had a Rewards Checking account. Other banks differ.

The page asks for deposits, not a balance you must keep. So the table tries two balances: $1,000 and $7,500, which is everything staying in the account. It also tries two waits. One is 90 days. The other is 174 days, which is 90 days plus the 12-week (84-day) payout wait the page describes as a maximum. That is a worst case for the math, not a promise. Savings is a made-up 4.00%, and the account is assumed to pay no interest.

$1,000
Days
90
Bonus wins by
$290.14
Break-even rate
121.67%
$1,000
Days
174
Bonus wins by
$280.93
Break-even rate
62.93%
$7,500
Days
90
Bonus wins by
$226.03
Break-even rate
16.22%
$7,500
Days
174
Bonus wins by
$156.99
Break-even rate
8.39%

At every balance here, the bonus pays more than savings. That assumes the made-up 4.00%. It leaves out tax, your hours and whether you qualify. You also lose the bonus if you close the account before it is paid. If the break-even rate is below the savings rate you can get, skip the offer. That is a fine result.

Chapter 3 deep diveAre Bank Bonuses Taxable? What to Expect at Tax TimeNext, tax: how a cash bonus and savings interest are each taxed, and what the after-tax figure looks like.

Limits of this guide.

  • This is education, not tax or financial advice.
  • It assumes simple interest and a flat savings rate. If your savings rate falls, the interest you give up falls too.
  • Only your own records can tell you your balance.

Want to run your own numbers? Try the bank bonus vs savings calculator.

Frequently asked questions

How do I compare a bank bonus with a savings account?

Put the same balance in both for the same number of days. Savings earns balance x rate x days / 365. The bonus account earns the bonus plus any interest it pays. The difference is how much the bonus wins by. The break-even rate is bonus / balance x 365 / days. Savings pays more whenever its rate is above that.

Does a bonus account usually pay interest on the balance?

It varies by account and offer, so read the account's rate disclosure. If the account pays little or nothing, as many checking accounts do, you give up all the savings interest on the money you keep there. If it pays some interest, subtract that.

Does this comparison work for money I spend each month?

No. Paychecks that arrive and leave within days leave almost nothing in the account to earn a savings rate. The comparison applies to money that really sits there. Use your honest average balance. A figure higher than you really keep makes the bonus look worse than it is.

Is the savings rate in the examples a current rate?

No. The 4.00% in the tables is a made-up number to show the steps. Current savings rates change. The chapter shows the best savings rate we track, refreshed with each site build, next to the break-even rates. Use the rate you can really get.

Get the week's biggest rate changes in savings, CDs and mortgages, free.

Or run your Money Map in 90 seconds.

Send me the weekly SwitchWize rate briefing: the biggest changes in savings, money market, checking and CD rates. Unsubscribe in one click. We never share your address.