Lock or wait? CD strategy when rates are rising

By the SwitchWize Research Desk

The short answer

Lock a CD now, wait, or break my current CD to re-lock at a higher rate.

Break a CD only if the new APY beats your break-even APY, which your penalty and the months you have left set. If you are buying a new CD, compare today's rate with what savings pays while you wait. Waiting wins only if you assume a higher rate later, and that guess is yours to make.

Rates as of The FOMC raised its target range on September 16, 2026. If your CD was opened before that, your break-even math may have changed.

Top savings APY

4.40%

As of 2026-11-16

National average savings

0.38%

As of 2026-11-16

Top CD APY

5.00%

As of 2026-11-16

Yearly gap on $10,000

$402

As of 2026-11-16

Break and re-lock, or lock now versus wait

Starts at the national 12-month CD average. Use the APY on your statement.

Find this in your CD agreement. Some banks state it in days; divide by 30.

Starts at the top CD APY across terms in our snapshot. Use the APY for the term you would actually buy.

$246

more by breaking the CD

Break-even new APY: 2.14%

Breaking pays by $246.

Early withdrawal penalty
$43
Interest if you hold to maturity
$171
Interest at the new APY, before penalty
$460
Net of penalty if you break
$417
How we calculated this

Interest over the remaining months is balance x ((1 + APY)^(months / 12) - 1), using APY, which already includes compounding. The penalty is balance x old APY / 12 x penalty months, a simple-interest estimate; your CD agreement controls the real figure. Net gain from breaking = new-CD interest - penalty - interest you would have earned by holding. It assumes the full balance moves to the new CD and the new CD matures when the old one would have. The break-even APY is the new rate at which that net gain is zero, found by bisection.

Your number

$246

more by breaking the CD

Open share image

The image shows only this result. The copied link includes the numbers you entered.

Interest earned: hold versus break and re-lock

Interest earned: hold versus break and re-lock. At month 12: Hold current CD $171, Break and re-lock $417.

  • Hold current CD
  • Break and re-lock
Interest earned: hold versus break and re-lock
MonthHold current CDBreak and re-lock
0$0-$43
1$14-$5
2$28$32
3$42$70
4$57$108
5$71$146
6$85$185
7$99$223
8$114$262
9$128$300
10$142$339
11$157$378
12$171$417

Find your situation

What are you deciding?

When the Fed raises rates, the CD you already own can start to feel like a mistake. Whether it is one comes down to arithmetic you can finish in two minutes: what leaving costs, against what the new rate earns in the months you have left.

Should I lock in a CD now or wait for rates to rise more?

Nobody can say where rates go next, so ask how much higher a later rate would need to be before waiting beats locking today. The Federal Reserve raised its target range on September 16, 2026.1 The top CD APY across terms in our snapshot is 5.00%, against a national 12-month average of 1.71%.

Switch the calculator to Lock now or wait. It starts with the later CD APY set equal to today's, meaning no change expected. Raise it to see what your own guess is worth in dollars.

Here is a hypothetical. You have $10,000 and can lock a 12-month CD at 5.00 percent today, or hold it in savings at 4.00 percent for three months first. The calculator also assumes the locked money earns the savings rate for the same three months after the CD ends, so both paths run equally long. If you assume a later CD rate of 5.50 percent, waiting comes out about $50 ahead. If the later rate is 4.50 percent, locking now comes out about $50 ahead. The swing is about $50 either way, so your guess about the later rate has to be a confident one to justify the wait.

Should I break my CD for a higher rate?

Break it only when the replacement APY is above your break-even APY, and the size of that gap sets your gain. Hold it if the replacement falls short.

Break-even depends on three things: how much interest the penalty costs, how many months remain, and how long the new CD runs. Take a hypothetical $25,000 in a CD at 3.00 percent APY with 18 months left and a penalty of six months of interest, which is $375. The replacement has to pay about 3.98 percent APY to break even. At 4.50 percent, breaking pays about $198 more than holding.

With only 3 months left and the same penalty, the break-even climbs to about 9.27 percent APY, far above the top CD rate in our snapshot, 5.00%. A new rate needs time to earn back the penalty. The chart in the calculator shows it: the break line starts below zero by the penalty and has to catch up.

One check before you break: if the penalty is larger than the interest your CD has earned so far, ask your bank whether the shortfall comes out of principal. Get the answer in writing.

What does a short CD ladder do when rates are rising?

A short ladder gives you a maturing rung every few months, so you can re-lock at whatever rate is on offer then without paying a penalty. The short rungs may start at a lower rate than one long CD.

Here is a three-rung ladder on the same amount, with one rung maturing every four months. Each maturity lets you buy whatever rate is then on offer.

Three rungs, one maturing every four months
  • Rung 14 mo
  • Rung 28 mo
  • Rung 312 mo

Three horizontal bars show CD terms of 4, 8 and 12 months, so a rung matures every four months.

The full build, with rung sizes and costs, is in the CD ladder blueprint. For the penalty mechanics and the break-even formula in depth, see CD anatomy and the early withdrawal penalty.

Are bump-up and no-penalty CDs worth it?

They can be, if you value the exit or the raise more than the lower starting rate. Our rate data does not rank those variants by APY, so compare their terms directly.

A bump-up CD lets you raise your rate if the bank raises its offer. A no-penalty CD lets you leave for a better rate, often after an initial waiting period. Read the bump-up and add-on CD guide and the no-penalty CD guide before you pay for either feature.

Below are the top standard CD offers in our current data, for the baseline you are comparing against.

What happens to the penalty at tax time?

You can generally deduct the penalty, which softens the cost of breaking a CD. It is reported in box 2 of Form 1099-INT (box 3 of Form 1099-OID for some CDs) and deducted on Schedule 1. You still report all of the interest.2 You do not need to itemize.

The calculator leaves taxes out. The penalty is generally deductible, which reduces its cost after tax, but the interest on the new CD is taxable too, so the after-tax gain from breaking is smaller than the calculator shows. This is general information, not tax advice.

What should I do next?

Put your own numbers in the calculator, then check the maturity date on any CD you own. Our CD maturity decision tool walks through what to do when one comes due, and saved CD alerts can warn you before it does.

If your savings account has not moved since the Fed acted, see did your bank pass on the rate hike. The Fed hike tracker shows the decision in context. If you decide to move your savings to a better rate, the bank switching checklist covers the order of steps.

Key facts

  • The FOMC approved a statement 12 to 0 on September 16, 2026 raising the federal funds target range by one quarter of a point, to 3.75 to 4.00 percent (Federal Reserve statement).
  • On $10,000 in a CD paying 4.00 percent APY with 12 months left and a 3-month interest penalty, a replacement CD must pay 5.00 percent APY to break even (SwitchWize break-and-re-lock calculator, hypothetical example, September 30, 2026).
  • A CD early withdrawal penalty is reported in box 2 of Form 1099-INT (box 3 of Form 1099-OID for some CDs) and is generally deductible as an adjustment to income on Schedule 1, without itemizing, while the interest itself stays taxable (IRS Publication 550 for 2025 and the Form 1099-INT recipient instructions, read 2026-10-03).

What to do next

Top live rates right now

  • Popular Direct, 5-year CD5% APY
  • Quorum Federal Credit Union, 4-year CD5% APY
  • Quorum Federal Credit Union, 5-year CD5% APY
Compare all accounts

Questions people ask

Should I lock in a CD now or wait for rates to rise more?

Nobody can say where rates go next. Switch the calculator to Lock now or wait, enter the CD APY you would assume later, and read the dollar difference. If the difference is small, locking now buys certainty for little cost.

How do I know if breaking my CD is worth it?

Compare the new APY with your break-even APY. Break-even is the new rate at which the interest you gain exactly covers the penalty and the interest you give up. Above it, breaking pays; below it, holding wins.

Can the early withdrawal penalty take my principal?

It can. If the penalty is larger than the interest your CD has earned so far, some banks take the difference from principal. Read your account agreement or ask your bank before you break a young CD.

Is a CD early withdrawal penalty tax deductible?

Generally yes. The penalty appears on Form 1099-INT (or Form 1099-OID for some CDs) and is deducted as an adjustment to income on Schedule 1, so you do not need to itemize. This is general information, not tax advice.

What if I want a rising-rate CD without a penalty risk?

Bump-up and no-penalty CDs are built for this case, and they can start at a lower rate than a standard CD of the same term. Our rate data does not rank them yet, so compare their terms in the linked guides.

Methodology and sources

Data

Live rates come from the SwitchWize Canonical Market Data Layer. Snapshot 2026-11-16v2 as of . Calculators assume daily compounding unless the calculator says otherwise.

Rules and program facts

  1. On September 16, 2026 the Federal Open Market Committee approved a statement, by a 12 to 0 vote, raising the target range for the federal funds rate by 1/4 percentage point (25 basis points), from 3-1/2 to 3-3/4 percent to 3-3/4 to 4 percent (3.50-3.75 to 3.75-4.00). The Federal Reserve's implementation note makes the new range effective September 17, 2026. Federal Reserve Board, FOMC statement and implementation note, September 16, 2026; Board open market operations page (target range history), verified .
  2. Interest or principal you forfeit because of an early withdrawal from a CD or other time deposit is shown in box 2 of Form 1099-INT (box 3 of Form 1099-OID for some deferred-interest accounts). You still report all of the interest, and you deduct the forfeited amount on Schedule 1 (Form 1040), Part II, as an adjustment to income in figuring adjusted gross income, so the deduction does not depend on itemizing. IRS, Publication 550 (2025), Investment Income and Expenses ("Penalty on early withdrawal of savings"); Form 1099-INT recipient instructions (Rev. January 2024); 26 U.S.C. 62(a)(9), verified .

Other sources

Reviewed by the SwitchWize Research Desk. Educational content, not financial, tax or legal advice. Spot an error? Tell us.

Get the week's biggest rate changes in savings, CDs and mortgages, free.

Or run your Money Map in 90 seconds.

Send me the weekly SwitchWize rate briefing: the biggest changes in savings, money market, checking and CD rates. Unsubscribe in one click. We never share your address.