SwitchWize decision guide

Morgan Stanley Savings vs E*TRADE Calculator: Which Pays You More Interest?

All three are insured deposits, and two of them sit at the same bank. They differ in the rate, who can open them, and how long the rate lasts. This calculator shows the interest in dollars. It also tells you when an account is not open to you.

SwitchWize Research DeskUpdated November 15, 2026Data checked November 15, 20265 min read

What you can expect

  • No login required
  • No credit pull
  • Assumptions shown
  • Sources included

Quick answer

Signature Savings earns the most over a year or more, but only Morgan Stanley clients can open it. E*TRADE Premium Savings earns about the same in year one, then falls to its base rate. The Preferred Savings Program pays the least of the three.

Signature Savings pays 4.00%. E*TRADE Premium Savings pays 4.25% for 6 months, then 3.75%. The Preferred Savings Program pays 3.60%. With $25,000 for 12 months, that is about $1,000, $1,000 and $900 in interest. Signature Savings is open only to Morgan Stanley clients.

Read the full comparison

If signature Savings

Pays the most over a year or longer. You must be a Morgan Stanley client, and the account is for individual and joint owners.

If E*TRADE Premium

Opens through E*TRADE with no minimum. It pays more for the first 6 months, then drops to its base rate.

If preferred Savings

Takes trusts, companies and retirement accounts, and deposits up to $20 million. It pays less and needs money from outside Morgan Stanley.

Key number to watch

With these rates, Signature Savings has earned at least as much as E*TRADE by month 12.

How we calculated this

Test your situation

See your result in dollars

Change any number below to match your situation. No login is required. Saved decisions stay on this device, and signed-in users can revisit them across devices.

$

The money you plan to deposit on day one. Enter the amount you would move, not your whole net worth.

mo

The calculator adds no deposits or withdrawals. Interest on the interest is included.

Morgan Stanley says you must be a client to open Signature Savings. Choose no if you only have an E*TRADE account or no account.

Choose yes for cash from another bank or from selling securities. The Preferred Savings Program does not take cash already held at Morgan Stanley.

Whose name is the account in?

Signature Savings is for individual and joint accounts. The Preferred Savings Program also takes trusts, companies and retirement accounts.

Your answer so far

On $25,000 for 12 months, Signature Savings and E*TRADE Premium Savings land within $10 of each other, at about $1,000 each. Choose between them on who can open it and how you want to manage it.

See the full breakdown

On $25,000 for 12 months, Signature Savings and E*TRADE Premium Savings land within $10 of each other, at about $1,000 each. Choose between them on who can open it and how you want to manage it.

Signature Savings

$1,000

interest over 12 months

E*TRADE Premium

$1,000

interest over 12 months

-$0 vs. baseline

Preferred Savings

$900

interest over 12 months

-$100 vs. baseline

Try a scenario

What could change this

With these rates, Signature Savings has earned at least as much as E*TRADE by month 12.

How certain: moderate

The program takes only Qualifying Cash: money from another bank or from selling securities.

How certain: high

What matters most

Most interest on your balance

depends

About $0 ahead of E*TRADE Premium Savings over 12 months.

Easiest to open

E*TRADE Premium

E*TRADE Premium Savings opens online with no Morgan Stanley relationship and no minimum deposit.

Side-by-side comparison

Rate

Signature Savings
4.00% on every balance
E*TRADE Premium
4.25% for 6 months, then 3.75%
Preferred Savings
3.60%

Who can open it

Signature Savings
Morgan Stanley clients
E*TRADE Premium
Open through E*TRADE
Preferred Savings
Morgan Stanley brokerage clients

Minimum to open

Signature Savings
None
E*TRADE Premium
None
Preferred Savings
$1,000

Account fees

Signature Savings
None
E*TRADE Premium
None
Preferred Savings
None

Account types

Signature Savings
Individual and joint
E*TRADE Premium
Ask E*TRADE
Preferred Savings
Individual, joint, trust, company and retirement

Withdrawal limit

Signature Savings
None stated
E*TRADE Premium
None stated
Preferred Savings
10 a month

What could go wrong

Morgan Stanley Signature Savings

What needs to work
You are a Morgan Stanley client and the rate stays near 4.00%.
Common problem
Planning around it before you confirm you qualify as a client.
What it could cost
Time spent moving money, then learning the account is closed to you.
How to prepare
Easy to reverse. You can move the money out at any time.

E*TRADE Premium Savings

What needs to work
You expect the rate to be close to the base rate after 6 months, and you plan for that.
Common problem
Counting the 4.25% rate for the whole year.
What it could cost
About half a point of yield a year compared with Signature Savings after the intro period.
How to prepare
Easy to reverse. You can move the money out at any time.

Morgan Stanley Preferred Savings Program

What needs to work
You have a trust, company or retirement account, or a very large deposit, and the money comes from outside.
Common problem
Trying to move cash already at Morgan Stanley into the program.
What it could cost
A lower rate than the other two for the same balance.
How to prepare
Withdrawals go through your Morgan Stanley team and are limited to 10 a month.

A simple backup plan

Check who can open each account first

Two answers rule accounts in or out before any math.

  1. 1Check whether you are a Morgan Stanley client. If not, Signature Savings and the Preferred Savings Program are closed to you.
  2. 2Check whose name is on the account. Trusts, companies and retirement accounts can use only the Preferred Savings Program, or E*TRADE if it accepts them.
  3. 3Enter your amount and how long you will keep it. Compare the dollars, not just the rates.
  4. 4Confirm the current rate with the bank before you move money.

Educational illustration only. The right amount depends on your needs and timing.

What to do next

  1. Question 1

    Are you a Morgan Stanley client with an individual or joint account?

    Yes: Signature Savings pays the most, so compare it with E*TRADE.

    No: Look at E*TRADE Premium Savings, or the Preferred Savings Program for a trust or company.

  2. Question 2

    Will you keep the money longer than 6 months?

    Yes: E*TRADE drops to its base rate, so Signature Savings pulls ahead.

    No: The E*TRADE intro rate keeps it level or ahead.

  3. Question 3

    Is the money coming from outside Morgan Stanley?

    Yes: The Preferred Savings Program is open to you.

    No: The Preferred Savings Program does not take cash already at Morgan Stanley.

Plain-text decision tree. Are you a Morgan Stanley client with an individual or joint account? If yes, Signature Savings pays the most, so compare it with E*TRADE. If no, Look at E*TRADE Premium Savings, or the Preferred Savings Program for a trust or company. Will you keep the money longer than 6 months? If yes, E*TRADE drops to its base rate, so Signature Savings pulls ahead. If no, The E*TRADE intro rate keeps it level or ahead. Is the money coming from outside Morgan Stanley? If yes, The Preferred Savings Program is open to you. If no, The Preferred Savings Program does not take cash already at Morgan Stanley.

When to check again

  • Morgan Stanley or E*TRADE changes a rate or the intro period.
  • You become a Morgan Stanley client.
  • Your balance changes by a large amount.
  • The E*TRADE intro offer ends on 1/10/2027.

Methodology

Each rate is a yearly yield. Your balance grows by one plus the rate, raised to the power of months divided by 12. E*TRADE uses its intro rate for the intro months and its base rate after that. An account you cannot open is left out of the ranking.

The starting rates are the rates each bank showed on the day we read its pages. Replace them with the rate you are offered.

  • • The calculator assumes every rate stays the same. All three can change at any time.
  • • It adds no deposits or withdrawals after day one.
  • • It does not include taxes. Interest on all three is taxable income.
  • • FDIC limits are not part of the interest result. Check each account page for how much of your balance is covered.
  • • This is education, not advice to open any account.

Rates and terms are re-read from each bank every month. The guide stops answering if they are older than 30 days. Editorial conclusions do not depend on affiliate availability.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Which pays more, Signature Savings or E*TRADE Premium Savings?

Signature Savings pays more over a year or longer. E*TRADE pays 4.25% for the first 6 months, then 3.75%. On $25,000 the two earn about the same in year one. In the second year Signature earns about $65 more.

Are Signature Savings and E*TRADE Premium Savings the same bank?

Yes. Both are held at Morgan Stanley Private Bank, National Association, Member FDIC. They differ in who can open them, the rate, and how you open them.

Can I open Signature Savings if I only have E*TRADE?

Morgan Stanley says you must be a Morgan Stanley client. Its page does not say whether an E*TRADE-only account counts, so ask Morgan Stanley before you plan around it.

What is Qualifying Cash?

It is cash from another bank, or money from selling securities in your eligible Morgan Stanley brokerage accounts. Cash already held at Morgan Stanley does not count for the Preferred Savings Program.

Why is the Preferred Savings Program rate lower?

Morgan Stanley advertises 3.60% for it. It is a brokerage program, set up through an advisor, and it takes trusts, companies and large deposits. The rate is dated, so check your statement.

Does the calculator include taxes?

No. Interest on all three accounts is taxable income. Your tax rate lowers each result by about the same share, so it rarely changes which account pays the most.

How current are the rates?

We read each rate from the bank on 11/15/2026. Banks can change rates at any time, so confirm the current rate before you move money. Replace any starting rate with the one you are offered.

Continue the decision

Get the week's biggest rate changes in savings, CDs and mortgages, free.

Or run your Money Map in 90 seconds.

Send me the weekly SwitchWize rate briefing: the biggest changes in savings, money market, checking and CD rates. Unsubscribe in one click. We never share your address.