Reality Index

What premium cards are worth after real-life breakage.

We compare advertised card value with realistic value recovered after annual fees, statement-credit breakage, redemption friction, and interest drag.

Default segment

Occasional traveler

A few trips per year, some portal use, moderate dining and grocery spend.

Annual spend

$36,000

Top modeled card

Capital One Venture X Rewards Credit Card

Strong fit

Capital One Venture X Rewards Credit Card

Source verified 2026-07-02

Advertised

$750

Realistic net

$921

Reality score

123%

Interest drag

$0

Rewards

$1,125

Credits used

$240

Perks used

$120

Annual fee

-$395

Friction

-$169

Credits are haircut by segment behavior; they are not counted at 100% unless the segment supports it.

Weak fit

The Platinum Card from American Express

Source verified 2026-07-02

Advertised

$1,550

Realistic net

$455

Reality score

29%

Interest drag

$0

Rewards

$750

Credits used

$338

Perks used

$175

Annual fee

-$695

Friction

-$113

Credits are haircut by segment behavior; they are not counted at 100% unless the segment supports it.

Weak fit

Chase Sapphire Reserve

Source verified 2026-07-02

Advertised

$1,200

Realistic net

$300

Reality score

25%

Interest drag

$0

Rewards

$750

Credits used

$283

Perks used

$175

Annual fee

-$795

Friction

-$113

Credits are haircut by segment behavior; they are not counted at 100% unless the segment supports it.

Modeled segments

Homebody cash-back user

Mostly grocery, dining, gas, and online spend with little paid travel.

Occasional traveler

A few trips per year, some portal use, moderate dining and grocery spend.

Frequent domestic traveler

Monthly domestic travel, meaningful portal or airline spend, and steady dining spend.

Premium travel optimizer

High travel spend, lounge value, transfer partners, and active credit tracking.

Small-business owner

Heavy general and travel spend, but credit recovery depends on admin discipline and clear expense tracking.

Balance carrier

Carries a revolving balance; rewards are tested against interest drag first.