Research Deskmortgage rate lock-in effectmortgage lock-inwhy homeowners won't sell

The Mortgage Rate Lock-In Effect: Why Homeowners With a 3% Rate Won't Sell

Millions of homeowners hold a mortgage rate the market will never offer again. Federal Housing Finance Agency research shows what that costs the housing market.

The short answer

Mortgage rate lock-in is the tendency of homeowners with a rate well below today's market rate to avoid selling, because moving means financing a new home at a much higher rate. A March 2024 Federal Housing Finance Agency working paper found each 1-point gap between a homeowner's locked-in rate and the current rate cuts the odds they sell by 18.1%, and estimates the effect prevented 1.33 million home sales between mid-2022 and the end of 2023 while pushing national home prices up 5.7%. Behavioral economists tie the resistance to the endowment effect: people demand more to give up something they already own than they'd pay to acquire it.

·Updated Nov 19, 2026·9 min read
First published Jul 8, 2026·Methodology →
A slate house stands chained by its chimney to a low pedestal of gold coins, while an open gate leads toward a taller, brighter stack of coins just beyond reach.
The house could move to something bigger. The chain won't let it.

The short answer

The mortgage rate lock-in effect is the tendency of homeowners with a low rate to avoid selling, because a move means a new loan at today's higher rate. Federal Housing Finance Agency researchers found each 1-point gap cuts the odds of a sale by 18.1%. They estimate 1.33 million sales did not happen.

A homeowner with a 2.9% mortgage is not just holding loan terms. They are holding something the market will never sell them again at that price. New research shows they treat it exactly like an asset they own.

How big is the mortgage rate lock-in effect?

In March 2024, four Federal Housing Finance Agency economists published a working paper. The authors were Ross Batzer, Jonah Coste, William Doerner and Michael Seiler. They found that each percentage point by which today's rate exceeds a homeowner's own rate cuts the odds they sell by 18.1%.

Run that across the country and the paper estimates 1.33 million sales did not happen between mid-2022 and the end of 2023. Fewer homes for sale meant less competition pushing prices down. The researchers found the scarcity added 5.7% to national home prices. That more than offset the 3.3% price drop higher rates should have caused on their own.

Higher rates were supposed to cool the housing market. By freezing supply harder than demand, they made homes cost more. The chain runs in a straight line.

  1. A higher rate makes a new mortgage more expensive.
  2. That makes moving more expensive for anyone holding a cheap loan.
  3. Those owners keep their homes off the market.
  4. Resales set prices for most U.S. housing, so prices stay high.

How many homeowners have a low rate?

Rates under 3% in 2020 and 2021 look, in hindsight, less like a mortgage and more like a subsidy. Then the Fed raised rates at the fastest pace in four decades. Mortgage rates went past 7% at the 2023 peak and have stayed far above the 2020 lows. See the live number at the Freddie Mac survey, or our mortgage rates page, which shows 7.40% for a 30-year fixed loan today.

In the third quarter of 2025, about half of mortgage holders still paid under 4%, per Federal Housing Finance Agency data tracked by Redfin. In that quarter 21.2% paid 6% or more, and 20% still paid under 3%. Redfin called that a first in five years. The country now has about as many owners locked into today's expensive money as into the pandemic's cheap money.

What does a low mortgage rate save you?

Here is a hypothetical example. You owe $400,000 on a 30-year loan, so the numbers are easy to compare.

  • At 2.9%, principal and interest is about $1,665 a month.
  • At 6.5%, it is about $2,528 a month.
  • The gap is about $863 a month, or $10,360 a year.
  • Over seven years, that is about $72,500 for the same size loan.

That figure leaves out property tax and insurance. It also shows why a move is a bigger decision than a bigger house. You can run your own numbers with our mortgage calculator and the refinance break-even calculator.

Why won't homeowners give up a low rate?

None of this needs irrational people. It is the same habit people show with anything they own. In 1990, Daniel Kahneman, Jack Knetsch and Richard Thaler gave some people a coffee mug. They asked what the owners would sell it for. They asked other people what they would pay to buy one. The typical seller wanted about twice what the typical buyer offered.

They called this the endowment effect. It rests on a finding by Kahneman and Amos Tversky that a loss hurts more than an equal gain feels good.

Put a 2.9% mortgage through that lens. The rate has become something the owner holds, with a value they can work out every time a friend mentions today's rate. Giving it up does not feel like accepting a normal rate. It feels like a loss.

What do homeowners say about selling?

A 2025 Bankrate and YouGov survey found 54% of homeowners said no rate would make them comfortable selling that year. The year before it was 42%. A separate Clever Real Estate and Best Interest Financial survey found 35% of owners with a rate under 6% would not give it up under any circumstances.

A 2026 survey of more than 3,000 Florida homeowners, reported by public radio station WLRN, went further. It found 35% had delayed a major life decision to keep their rate, and moving closer to family was the most common reason. If you do need to move, the ARM versus fixed rate choice matters more when today's rate feels less permanent.

Will the lock-in effect ever end?

There is a slow counter-trend. As more owners hold a rate of 6% or higher, fewer have a cheap rate to protect. Mostly, though, the freeze thaws the way these things usually do. People do not change their minds about the rate. Life forces the move: a new job, a divorce or a family that has outgrown a starter home.

If you are weighing a move, run the numbers before assuming the rate rules it out. Read our guide on whether to refinance and check where rates sit today before deciding the gap is too big to cross. The housing market statistics page shows how few homes are for sale.

This article is educational and is not financial or mortgage advice. The $400,000 example is a hypothetical.

Sources

Common questions

What is the mortgage rate lock-in effect?

It is the habit of homeowners with a low mortgage rate to stay put, because a move means a new loan at today's higher rate. FHFA research ties every 1-point gap between the two rates to an 18.1% drop in the odds a homeowner sells.

How many home sales has rate lock-in prevented?

FHFA researchers estimate about 1.33 million sales that would otherwise have happened did not happen between mid-2022 and the end of 2023. They also estimate it pushed national home prices up by 5.7%.

Is the mortgage rate lock-in effect getting better?

Slowly. Each year more owners hold a 6% or higher rate, so fewer have a cheap rate to protect. Most of the thaw comes from life events, such as a job change, a divorce or a growing family, that force a move anyway.

Should I keep my low mortgage rate or sell?

Compare the full monthly cost of the new home with what you pay now, not only the rate. A low rate is worth real money, but it should not trap you in a home that no longer fits your job, family or budget.

Can a new buyer take over my low-rate mortgage?

Usually not. Most conventional loans have a due-on-sale clause, which means the loan is repaid when the home is sold. FHA and VA loans can sometimes be assumed, but the buyer must qualify and pay you the difference in price.

Connect the lesson

Turn the article into a next step.

Recommended: Plan for home

SwitchWize takeaway

Find your number, not the market's.

Run a Money Map to see how your cash, debt, and rates stack up against the best available options.

Start Money Map →

Figures are third-party research and survey data, not SwitchWize proprietary research: FHFA Working Paper 24-03 (Batzer, Coste, Doerner, Seiler, March 2024), Fonseca & Liu, "Mortgage Lock-In, Mobility, and Labor Reallocation," Journal of Finance (2024), Redfin's rate distribution reports (Q2 2025 and Q3 2025), a Bankrate/YouGov mortgage sentiment survey, a Clever Real Estate/Best Interest Financial survey, and a Calgary Homes survey of Florida homeowners (2026, via WLRN). Reviewed November 19, 2026. The $400,000 example at 2.9% and 6.5% is a hypothetical, worked out with the standard 30-year payment formula, not a real household.

The week's biggest rate changes, in your inbox every Monday. Free.

Savings, CDs and mortgages: the best rates and what moved.

See what is inside

Send me the weekly SwitchWize rate briefing: the biggest changes in savings, money market, checking and CD rates. Unsubscribe in one click. We never share your address.