Research Deskmoney illusioninflation psychologyreal wages

Why Your Raise Doesn't Feel Like a Raise

In May 2026, U.S. consumer sentiment hit its lowest reading since 1952, even as retail sales stayed strong. A hundred-year-old idea explains the gap, and it predicts the opposite of what actually happened.

The short answer

Money illusion is the well-documented tendency to judge financial outcomes by their nominal dollar value instead of their inflation-adjusted, real value, first named by economist Irving Fisher in 1928 and demonstrated experimentally by Eldar Shafir, Peter Diamond, and Amos Tversky in a 1997 study. It predicts people should feel better about a nominal raise than the real math justifies, not worse, yet U.S. consumer sentiment hit a record low in 2026 even as dollar wages kept climbing. The gap is driven less by miscalculation than by how much more often price pain is felt compared to a single yearly raise, plus rising fear about specific future costs like rent and medical care.

·Updated Oct 22, 2026·7 min read
First published Jul 8, 2026·Methodology →
An oversized gold coin rests on one side of a balance scale, its pan hanging no lower than the modest stack of goods across from it.
The coin got bigger. It buys exactly what it always did.

In 1928, a year before the crash that would make him famous for being wrong about something else entirely, economist Irving Fisher named a bias he'd spent years watching trip up savers and investors: "failure to perceive that the dollar, or any other unit of money, expands or shrinks in value." He called it money illusion. Ninety-eight years later, in May 2026, U.S. consumer sentiment fell to its lowest level since the modern survey began in 1952, lower than the depths of the 2008 financial crisis, lower than the peak of the pandemic, even as retail sales kept growing from a year earlier. Fisher's century-old idea, and a thirty-year-old lab finding built on it, explain more of that gap than most of the coverage around it. They also point in the opposite direction of what actually happened. Understanding money illusion raise inflation psychology reveals why nominal wage gains feel hollow when purchasing power declines.

The gap that shouldn't exist

The University of Michigan's Consumer Sentiment Index, running continuously since 1952, fell to 44.8 in May 2026, the lowest reading in the survey's history. It had already dropped to 49.8 in April. It has since partly recovered, to 55.2 in July, before slipping back to 48.1 in September. One cause people pointed to was a Strait of Hormuz supply disruption that pushed gasoline prices sharply higher through the spring, a real shock, not a misperception. Meanwhile, spending kept growing: the Census Bureau's advance estimate put September 2026 retail sales up 6.3% from a year earlier, before adjusting for price changes. Economists call the divide between how people say they feel and what they actually do "soft data" versus "hard data," and in 2026 that gap opened wider than it had in the index's 74-year history.

Some of this has a plainly rational explanation. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that real average hourly earnings, the number that reflects purchasing power, fell 0.7% over the twelve months ending September 2026. Pay is rising in dollars, but prices are rising faster. Workers are getting nominal raises. They are not, on average, getting richer. That's a genuine kernel of truth inside the anxiety. But the size of the sentiment collapse is too large to explain with a wage number bouncing within a point of zero.

The 1997 experiment that predicts the opposite

In 1997, psychologist Eldar Shafir, economist Peter Diamond, and psychologist Amos Tversky published "Money Illusion" in the Quarterly Journal of Economics, a paper since replicated multiple times, including with a Brazilian sample as recently as 2024. Their core finding, demonstrated across Princeton undergraduates, airport travelers, and shopping-mall visitors, is that people evaluate financial outcomes using the nominal dollar figure first, and only weakly correct for inflation, if at all.

Their most cited illustration involves two hypothetical employees. Ann works through a year with zero inflation and gets a 2% raise: her purchasing power genuinely rises by the full 2%. Barbara works through a year with 4% inflation and gets a 5% raise, a bigger number, but after inflation her real gain is only about 1%, half of Ann's. Objectively, Ann is better off. Asked who is happier and better treated, most respondents picked Barbara, the one with the worse real outcome, because the bigger sticker number won, even though the math said it shouldn't.

Run that finding forward and it makes a specific prediction: after several years of rising nominal paychecks, people should feel reasonably good about their financial position, complacent even. That's the opposite of a record low. The textbook bias points the wrong way. A related 1996 Brookings paper by George Akerlof, William Dickens, and George Perry found employers avoid nominal pay cuts even when an equivalent real cut, delivered quietly through inflation, draws no resistance, a mechanism that should also produce complacency, not anxiety. Two well-established theories both predict calm. Sentiment posted its lowest reading since Harry Truman was president.

What actually breaks the illusion

Three things appear to be doing that work. First, a raise is one event, once a year; a grocery bill or gas pump is a near-daily reminder, and losses register roughly twice as intensely as equivalent gains, per Kahneman and Tversky's foundational work on loss aversion: a single positive event is structurally outmatched by dozens of smaller negative ones. Second, some of it isn't illusion at all: the Hormuz-driven gas spike was a real, highly visible price shock at the most frequently observed price in American life. Third, the anxiety may be aimed at the future, not the past: the New York Fed's Survey of Consumer Expectations found one-year-ahead inflation expectations climbing to 3.9% in September 2026, the highest reading since May 2023. People may not be misjudging the raise they already got. They may be rationally dreading the bills they can see coming.

The illusion shows up outside paychecks too. Malcolm Baker, Robin Greenwood, and Jeffrey Wurgler documented in a 2009 Journal of Finance paper that stock splits, a purely cosmetic move that changes nothing about a company's actual value, reliably produce a short-term price pop, because investors perceive the lower per-share price as having "more room to grow." It's why cost-of-living clauses exist in union contracts and Social Security at all: an institutional admission that individuals reliably don't correct for inflation on their own, so the adjustment gets built in automatically instead. A related reference-point bias shows up in how savers judge today's interest rates against the peak they got used to, rather than the much lower decade that came before it.

Federal Reserve research adds a caution about trusting either the vibe or the data too much on its own. A Kansas City Fed study found sentiment surveys have historically added little to forecasting actual consumer spending. The 2026 numbers bear that out: record-low sentiment in May, alongside retail sales that kept rising.

None of this resolves into "don't worry, it's all in your head." Real wages genuinely have been slipping, and that part isn't an illusion. It means the intensity of the anxiety is being amplified by mechanisms that have nothing to do with the number on your pay stub. Fisher's own diagnosis, written before he'd ever seen a smartphone or a same-day price alert, still names the fix: stop reading the dollar amount as the answer and start reading what it buys. If you want a cleaner read than either the sentiment headlines or the raw dollar figure, run your actual numbers and check them against inflation directly, rather than against how the last receipt or the last headline made you feel. And if the number still doesn't quiet the unease, that's a separate, well-documented pattern, not a sign the math is wrong.


This article is educational and is not financial or economic advice.

Sources

Quick answers

What is money illusion? The tendency to evaluate income, prices, and financial outcomes by their nominal, face-value dollar amount rather than their real, inflation-adjusted value, named by economist Irving Fisher in 1928 and demonstrated experimentally in a widely replicated 1997 study.

Why doesn't a raise feel like a raise right now? Dollar wages are rising, but real, inflation-adjusted hourly earnings fell 0.7% over the twelve months ending September 2026, per the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Shouldn't money illusion make people feel better about nominal raises, not worse? Yes, that's the counterintuitive part. The original 1997 research found people rate a bigger nominal raise as making someone happier and better-treated, even when a smaller nominal raise represented a larger real, inflation-adjusted gain. That effect predicts complacency about today's wage growth, not record-low sentiment.

Is consumer sentiment actually as bad as the headlines say? The University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment Index hit a record low in May 2026, the lowest since 1952, but retail sales kept growing from a year earlier, and Federal Reserve research has found only a modest historical link between sentiment surveys and actual spending.

Connect the lesson

Turn the article into a next step.

Recommended: Save smarter

SwitchWize takeaway

Find your number, not the market's.

Run a Money Map to see how your cash, debt, and rates stack up against the best available options.

Start Money Map →

Figures are third-party research and government data, not SwitchWize proprietary research: Shafir, Diamond & Tversky, "Money Illusion," Quarterly Journal of Economics (1997); Akerlof, Dickens & Perry, "The Macroeconomics of Low Inflation," Brookings Papers on Economic Activity (1996); Baker, Greenwood & Wurgler, "Catering Through Nominal Share Prices," Journal of Finance (2009); University of Michigan Surveys of Consumers (May 2026); U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics Real Earnings releases (2026); New York Fed Survey of Consumer Expectations (June 2026); Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, "Forecasting with Feelings." Reviewed October 22, 2026.

The week's biggest rate changes, in your inbox every Monday. Free.

Savings, CDs and mortgages: the best rates and what moved.

See what is inside

Send me the weekly SwitchWize rate briefing: the biggest changes in savings, money market, checking and CD rates. Unsubscribe in one click. We never share your address.