- Federal loans, scholarships, grants, and work-study come first: private loans are a last-mile funding tool, not a first resort.
- Choosing deferred repayment on a $15,000 loan at 7% over 10 years costs you roughly $1,400 more in total interest than making interest-only payments in school.
- Most undergraduates need a cosigner to qualify for private loans; a creditworthy cosigner can reduce your APR by 1 to 3 points, which adds up to thousands over a 10-year term.
The bottom line
Private student loans fill the funding gap after you have maxed federal loans, scholarships, grants, and work-study. They do not come with income-driven repayment, PSLF eligibility, or federal forbearance. Used strategically, in the right amount and with a strong repayment plan, they are a reasonable tool. Used carelessly, they can become expensive debt with few options if your income falls short after graduation.
Quick picks
| Best for | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Undergraduates | College Ave | No-fee, flexible repayment options, cosigner release at 24 months |
| Graduate students | Earnest | Merit-based underwriting, no cosigner needed for strong profiles |
| No-fee borrowing | College Ave | Zero fees across origination, application, and prepayment |
| Cosigner release | Sallie Mae | Cosigner release available; confirm current terms at salliemae.com |
| Professional programs | Ascent | Medical and dental school options with residency deferment |
| Interest-only in school | Sallie Mae | Clear interest-only option with defined terms |
Federal loans first: the rule that saves thousands
Before comparing any private loan, confirm you have used every dollar of your federal loan eligibility. For the 2025-26 academic year, undergraduate direct loan limits are $5,500 to $7,500 per year depending on dependency status and year in school. Graduate students can borrow up to $20,500 per year in Direct Unsubsidized loans. Federal loans carry income-driven repayment eligibility, PSLF eligibility, and standardized forbearance that private loans do not. Use them first. Private loans are a last-mile tool, not a first line of funding.
The priority order for funding higher education is:
- Scholarships and grants (no repayment required)
- Work-study and employment income (no debt)
- Federal Direct Subsidized loans (interest paused while enrolled at least half-time)
- Federal Direct Unsubsidized loans
- Parent PLUS loans (see the parent loans guide for trade-offs)
- Private student loans
Private loans appear last on this list because they are last in this priority. They cost more, protect less, and leave you with fewer options if your post-graduation income is lower than expected.
What the repayment choice costs you in school
This is one of the most consequential decisions in private student borrowing: what to pay while you are still enrolled.
Deferred repayment (no payments in school): Interest accrues during a 4-year undergraduate program and a 6-month grace period. At 7%, that is roughly $4,725 in accrued interest added to your principal before repayment begins. Starting balance at repayment: approximately $19,725. Monthly payment: $229. Total paid over 10 years: $27,478. Total interest paid: $12,478.
Interest-only payments in school: You pay roughly $87.50 per month during a 4-year program (4 years x 12 months x $87.50 = $4,200 total in-school payments). Balance at repayment start: $15,000 (no capitalization). Monthly payment: $174. Total paid: $4,200 in school + $20,880 in repayment = $25,080. Total interest paid: $10,080.
Immediate full repayment in school: Payments begin right away, reducing principal faster. Total interest paid over the loan life is lowest. Best for borrowers with part-time income or family support during school.
Savings from interest-only vs. deferred: approximately $2,398 in total interest over the life of the loan, plus lower monthly payments in repayment.
Verify current APR ranges with each lender before modeling your own numbers. These figures use a fixed 7% APR for illustration.
The practical takeaway: if you can afford to pay even interest-only while in school, do it. It meaningfully reduces your balance at graduation and keeps monthly payments manageable.
Do you need a cosigner?
Most undergraduates need a cosigner because they have limited credit history and little to no income. Graduate students with established credit and full-time employment may qualify without one. Here is how to think through the decision:
You likely need a cosigner if:
- You are a first- or second-year undergraduate
- You have little or no credit history (less than 2 years of accounts)
- Your annual income is under $20,000
- Your credit score is below 680
A cosigner can help even if you technically qualify, because:
- A creditworthy cosigner (score 740+) can reduce your APR by 1 to 3 points
- On $15,000 at 7% vs. 5.5% over 10 years, that difference is roughly $1,200 in total interest
- A lower rate also means a lower monthly payment, which matters if your post-graduation income is uncertain
What cosigning means for the cosigner:
- They are equally and fully liable for the loan. If you miss payments, they are responsible.
- The loan appears on their credit report and affects their debt-to-income ratio.
- This can affect their ability to get a mortgage, car loan, or other credit.
- Discuss this fully before asking anyone to cosign.
Cosigner release: free your cosigner after meeting requirements
A cosigner release lets you remove the cosigner from the loan after you meet the lender's criteria, typically a set number of on-time payments plus a credit and income review. Release timelines vary:
- College Ave: 24 consecutive on-time payments, subject to credit review
- Sallie Mae: After primary repayment period begins and other criteria are met; verify current terms at salliemae.com
- Earnest: Does not currently offer cosigned private student loans; confirm availability directly
- Ascent: Cosigner release available after certain payment thresholds; verify terms at ascentfunding.com
- Citizens Bank: Cosigner release after 36 months; confirm current terms at citizensbank.com
Until the release is granted, the cosigner's liability and credit exposure remain. Make it a goal to pursue release as soon as you qualify.
In-school repayment options, compared
| Repayment option | Monthly payment in school | Interest capitalizes? | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full deferment | $0 | Yes, fully | Borrowers with zero income in school |
| Interest-only | ~$87.50 on $15K at 7% | No | Borrowers with part-time income |
| Fixed small payment | $25 to $50 (varies by lender) | Partially reduced | Borrowers with limited income |
| Immediate full payment | Full amortizing | No | Borrowers with employment or family support |
Ask each lender which in-school options they offer before signing. Not all lenders offer all four tiers.
Grace period comparison
Most private lenders offer a 6-month grace period after graduation before repayment begins. Some offer extended grace for medical or dental residencies (verify with each lender). Interest typically continues to accrue during the grace period. If your lender capitalizes interest at the end of the grace period, your starting balance in repayment will be higher than your original borrowed amount. Know whether your lender capitalizes grace-period interest before you sign.
Top picks, detailed
College Ave: Best for undergraduates and no-fee borrowing
College Ave charges no application fee, no origination fee, and no prepayment penalty. It offers four in-school repayment options (deferred, interest-only, fixed payment, full payment) and cosigner release after 24 months of on-time payments. Loan terms range from 5 to 15 years. Rates are credit-dependent; get a rate estimate with a soft inquiry at collegeave.com.
Who should apply: Undergraduates with a creditworthy cosigner who want flexible in-school payment options and a path to cosigner release.
Who should skip: Borrowers who need longer terms or who have strong solo credit and want a lender that rewards merit-based underwriting more aggressively.
Sallie Mae: Best for clear in-school interest-only option
Sallie Mae is one of the largest private student lenders in the United States. It offers undergraduate, graduate, and specialty loans (medical, dental, law, MBA). The Smart Option Student Loan offers three in-school repayment choices: deferred, interest-only, and fixed payment. Cosigner release is available after meeting payment and creditworthiness criteria; verify current terms at salliemae.com.
Who should apply: Borrowers who want a large, established lender with clear in-school repayment options and a wide range of school types covered.
Who should skip: Borrowers who prioritize low fees above all else; compare total cost across lenders. Federal loan borrowers who have not yet exhausted their federal limits.
Earnest: Best for graduate students with strong credit
Earnest's merit-based underwriting looks beyond credit score to your education, savings rate, income trajectory, and employment. This can help graduate students with solid profiles who do not yet have a long credit history. Earnest offers flexible repayment terms and no fees. Verify current product availability (cosigner options vary) at earnest.com.
Who should apply: Graduate students with established credit, steady income, and no need for a cosigner who want a lender that rewards financial responsibility holistically.
Who should skip: Undergraduates with limited credit who need a cosigner (verify Earnest's current cosigner product availability directly). Borrowers who need more than 15 years to repay.
Ascent: Best for professional programs
Ascent specifically serves medical, dental, law, and MBA students with products tailored to the financial profile of professional school: large loan amounts, deferred repayment through training, and grace periods that match residency timelines. Ascent also offers non-cosigned loans for graduate students who meet credit and income thresholds. Verify current APR ranges and program availability at ascentfunding.com.
Who should apply: Medical, dental, or law students with high borrowing needs who want in-school deferment through residency and a lender that understands professional school timelines.
Who should skip: Undergraduates or community college students (Ascent's non-cosigned products have specific eligibility requirements). Anyone eligible for NHSC or PSLF with federal loans.
Discover Student Loans: Best for cashback reward at graduation
Discover offers a one-time 1% cashback reward on the loan principal if you graduate. This is not a rate reduction but a rebate paid after you complete your degree. Discover charges no fees and offers a 6-month grace period. Verify current APR ranges and cashback program terms at discover.com, as program terms can change.
Who should apply: Borrowers who want a no-fee lender with a straightforward cashback incentive tied to graduation.
Who should skip: Borrowers who need a cosigner release timeline shorter than Discover currently offers; verify current terms directly.
Citizens Bank: Best for multi-year approval
Citizens Bank offers a multi-year approval feature for undergraduate borrowers, meaning you can be approved for your total program borrowing needs upfront and receive funds each year without reapplying. This reduces credit inquiries and simplifies the annual borrowing process. Cosigner release is available after 36 months; verify current terms at citizensbank.com.
Who should apply: Undergraduates who want to lock in their borrowing approval across all four years without annual reapplications.
When this recommendation changes
Private loan rankings shift when: (1) a lender changes its APR range, fee structure, or underwriting criteria; (2) federal loan limits are adjusted by Congress, changing how much of your funding gap is left for private loans; (3) interest rates move significantly, which affects variable-rate offers more than fixed; (4) your credit profile changes between years, which can unlock better rates at different lenders than you used previously. Revisit lender comparisons each academic year before borrowing new funds.
How we ranked
SwitchWize ranked private student loan lenders on five factors: APR range (published low-to-high for fixed rates), fee structure (origination, application, prepayment, late fees), in-school repayment flexibility (how many options offered), cosigner options and release terms, and specialty program availability (professional school programs, medical residency deferment). Lenders receive affiliate compensation for applications made through SwitchWize links. This compensation does not affect our rankings. All rate claims should be verified directly with each lender, as rates and eligibility change frequently.
What to do next
What to Do Now
Weekly brief + instant notifications when rates move for you
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I take out private student loans before using up my federal loan limit?
Do I need a cosigner for a private student loan?
What is the difference between deferred and interest-only repayment in school?
How do I compare private student loan APRs when they show wide ranges?
Can private student loans be forgiven?
What happens if I cannot make my private student loan payments?
Do private student loans have grace periods after graduation?
Act on this: today's top loans



Ranked by SwitchWize's composite score. We may earn a referral fee, and it never changes the ranking order.
Editorial review
What changed since the last update
Was this guide helpful?